HarmonyBeginner3 min read

Perfect and imperfect authentic cadence: position, inversions, and closing strength

Definition

The authentic cadence is the dominant → tonic succession (V–I or V7–I) at the end of a phrase. Not all authentic cadences have the same strength: they are divided into perfect and imperfect according to the arrangement of the chords and the soprano note.

Perfect cadence

A perfect authentic cadence occurs when:

  1. both chords (V and I) are in root position;
  2. the soprano ends on the tonic (in C: soprano B → C or D → C);
  3. the arrival on the tonic occurs on a strong beat.

It is the most conclusive cadence in tonal music: it closes periods, sections, and pieces.

Imperfect cadence

The authentic cadence is imperfect if even one of the conditions is missing:

  • the soprano ends on the third or the fifth of the tonic (D → E, D → G);
  • one of the two chords is in inversion (V6–I, V–I6, V4/3–I);
  • instead of the V there is the vii°6 (dominant without root).

The imperfect cadence closes, but leaves the feeling that the discourse could continue.

Compound cadence

When the dominant is preceded by the cadential six-four (I6/4–V–I), we speak of a compound cadence. Combined with a predominant (ii6–I6/4–V7–I) it forms the most complete cadential formula of the Classical style.

Hierarchy of closures

CadenceStrength
Perfect (V–I, soprano on the tonic, strong beat)maximum
Imperfect (soprano on the third or fifth)medium
Imperfect with inversions (V6–I, V–I6)weak
Half cadence (ends on the V)suspensive
Deceptive (V–vi)avoided

Practical rules

  • Reserve the perfect cadence for important formal points: end of the period, end of a section, the finale.
  • Use the imperfect cadence to close internal phrases without stopping the flow.
  • In voice leading: the leading tone rises to the tonic, the seventh of the V7 falls to the third of the tonic. If the complete V7 resolves to an incomplete I (root tripled and third), it is correct.
  • The bass from the dominant to the tonic moves by descending fifth or ascending fourth.

Common mistakes

  • Ending a piece with an imperfect cadence without meaning to (soprano on the third): the ending sounds incomplete.
  • Putting the arrival tonic on a weak beat.
  • Using perfect cadences at every phrase: the music breaks into many closed blocks.

Examples

  • Beethoven, “Ode to Joy”: the second phrase ends with the soprano D → C over V–I: a perfect cadence that closes the period.
  • Bach chorales: the last phrase almost always ends with a perfect cadence, the internal phrases often with imperfect ones or half cadences.
  • Classical symphony finales: the insistent repetition of root-position V–I with the tonic in the soprano makes the closure unmistakable.
  • Pop: many intermediate choruses end on an IV or on a I with the third in the melody (imperfect closure); the last chorus closes with the melody on the tonic.

How to use it in composition

  • Plan cadences like the punctuation of a text: imperfect ones as commas and semicolons, perfect ones as periods.
  • In the chorus melody, choose consciously which degree to close on: tonic to close, third or fifth to leave it open.
  • If a piece seems to end too soon, turn an internal perfect cadence into an imperfect or deceptive one.

Exercise

  1. Write four authentic cadences in Eb major: perfect, imperfect with soprano on the third, imperfect with V6, imperfect with vii°6.
  2. Analyze the cadences of a Bach chorale and classify them.
  3. Rewrite the ending of a chorus of your own by changing the final note of the melody and evaluate the effect.

Connections

Cadences; Half cadence and Phrygian cadence; Deceptive cadence and variants; The six-four chord; The period: antecedent and consequent; Dominant seventh chord.

Sources

Related lessons