HarmonyAdvanced3 min read

Extended tonal functions (Riemann): T, S, D, parallels, and counter-chords

The idea

For Hugo Riemann, every chord of a key is a version of three functions: Tonic (T), Subdominant (S), and Dominant (D). The other chords are "representatives" of these three, linked by third relations. The system, simplified and spread by Wilhelm Maler and Diether de la Motte (Harmonielehre, 1976), is still the standard in conservatories in German-speaking and Scandinavian countries; Berklee uses a similar idea (families of tonic, subdominant, minor subdominant, and dominant).

Main symbols (in C major)

Uppercase letters = major chord, lowercase = minor.

SymbolNameChordDegree
TTonicCI
SSubdominantFIV
DDominantGV
TpParallel of the tonic (relative)Amvi
SpParallel of the subdominantDmii
DpParallel of the dominantEmiii
TgCounter-chord of the tonic (Gegenklang/Leittonwechsel)Emiii
SgCounter-chord of the subdominantAmvi
D7Dominant with seventhG7V7
D with a bar (shortened dominant)leading-tone seventh = D7 without rootB° / B°7vii°
DDDouble dominantD / D7V/V
(D)Secondary dominant toward the following chordA7 → DmV/ii
sMinor subdominant (in major)Fmiv
sN or snNeapolitan sixthDb/FbII6

Note: in German "Parallele" means relative (Am with respect to C), while the English "parallel" (Cm) is called Variante. This is the source of much confusion.

In minor (A minor)

SymbolChordDegree
tAmi
sDmiv
DE (with G#)V
tPCIII
sPFVI
dPGVII
tGFVI
sGBbbII (Neapolitan area)

Why it is useful

  • Clear ambiguity: Em in C can be Dp (close to the dominant: it substitutes for G) or Tg (close to the tonic: it substitutes for C). Context decides: G → Em is a deceptive cadence "toward the tonic"; Em → Am sounds like a continuation of the tonic.
  • Families by substitution: all T chords (C, Am, Em) can be swapped with one another; all S chords (F, Dm, Fm, Ab, Db) prepare the dominant.
  • Quick pop analysis: C Am F G = T Tp S D. The royal road IVmaj7 – V7 – iii7 – vi = S – D – Dp/Tg – Tp: a dominant that avoids the tonic and "slides" to its representatives.

Comparison with Berklee

FunctionRiemannBerklee (C major)
TonicT, Tp, TgImaj7, iii7, vi7
SubdominantS, Sp, SgIVmaj7, ii7
Minor subdominants, sP, sNiv7, bVImaj7, bVII7, iiø7, bIImaj7
DominantD, D7, shortened DV7, viiø7

Complete analysis example

Bach, Prelude in C, BWV 846, first 4 bars: C – Dm7/C – G7/B – C = T – Sp7 – D7 – T over a bass that stays on C and descends to B. In the following bars the music touches the double dominant (D7/C → G/B) and the subdominant: the function guides the arc even though the bass moves slowly.

Exercise

Analyze three of your own progressions with Riemann's symbols. Then replace each chord with another of the same function (C ↔ Am ↔ Em; F ↔ Dm ↔ Fm; G ↔ B°): you'll get reharmonizations that preserve the logic.

Diatonic functions T–S–D, diatonic substitution, neo-Riemannian theory, negative harmony (which swaps D and s), Neapolitan sixth.

Sources

Related lessons