HarmonyIntermediate3 min read

Phrygian: flamenco, Phrygian dominant, and metal

The Phrygian mode

E Phrygian: E F G A B C D (1 b2 b3 4 5 b6 b7). It is a minor scale with a minor second: the characteristic note is the b2 (F over E), which creates a semitone above the tonic: the sound is dark, tense, “Spanish” or “Eastern.”

Phrygian dominant

Raising the third gives the Phrygian dominant (5th mode of A harmonic minor): E F G# A B C D (1 b2 3 4 5 b6 b7). The augmented second F – G# gives the flamenco, klezmer, Middle Eastern, and “neoclassical metal” color.

Main chords (tonic E)

ChordModeDegreeRole
Em / EPhrygian / Phrygian dominanti / Itonic
F, Fmaj7bothbIIcharacteristic chord
GPhrygianbIII
Ambothiv
DmPhrygianbvii
CbothbVI
B° / Bm7b5v°avoid as a dominant

The typical cadence is bII – I (F → E): the “Phrygian cadence” (also iv6 – V in minor, in the classical tradition).

Flamenco

  • The Andalusian cadence Am – G – F – E is read as iv – bIII – bII – I in E Phrygian (dominant): it arrives on E major.
  • The “mode of E” is the center of flamenco guitar por arriba; por medio (tonic A, with Bb) is the transposition.
  • E chords in flamenco often have added notes with open strings (E – F – G in the voicings): the cluster with the b2 is part of the sound.
  • Misirlou (Dick Dale’s surf version, 1962) is based on E Phrygian dominant: E F G# A B C D.

Metal

  • Riffs lean on the lowest open string (E, D in drop D, C, B…) and use the b2 as a note of tension: E – F (semitone) is the quintessential Phrygian gesture of thrash and death metal.
  • Power chords a semitone apart: E5 – F5 – E5.
  • Phrygian dominant in neoclassical metal (Yngwie Malmsteen) and in folk/oriental metal: E major arpeggios with F.
  • Other “heavy” notes: b5 (Bb over E, the tritone) and b6 (C).

Phrygian in pop and rock

  • Jefferson Airplane, White Rabbit (1967): the alternation F# – G (I – bII) in a bolero rhythm.
  • Many trailers and action soundtracks use i – bII ostinatos (Em – F) in the low strings.

Arranging techniques

  • Tonic pedal (bass or open string) with bII and bIII chords above: bII/I (F/E) is the densest Phrygian sound.
  • Melodies that revolve around the tonic with the b2 as an upper “neighbor note”: E – F – E.
  • In Phrygian dominant, use the G# as a long note on the I and the F as an appoggiatura.

Common mistakes

  • Putting a B7 (V7) under the melody: it introduces F# and D#, erasing the Phrygian.
  • Confusing Phrygian and Aeolian: without the b2 heard often, the ear returns to natural minor.

Producer exercise

  1. Metal: guitar in drop D (D2 = 73.4 Hz), sixteenth-note riff on the open string with D – Eb – D and an Eb5 power chord on the fourth beat, 160 BPM.
  2. Flamenco/cinematic: palmas in 12 beats (or plain 4/4), nylon guitar with Am – G – F – E and a melody in E Phrygian dominant over the last chord.
  3. Compare the two worlds: same b2, two cultures.

Andalusian cadence, harmony in metal, harmony in minor keys, the modes of the major scale, harmony for film.

Sources

Related lessons